Evaluating single-use systems for extractables and leachables

 

BY DR TIM SANDLE | PHARMACEUTICAL MICROBIOLOGY AND CONTAMINATION CONTROL EXPERT

9th December

 

 

Sterile single-use disposable technologies present considerable advancements for pharmaceutical manufacturing, improving process design and reducing turnaround times. These technologies will have described chemical, toxicological, physical, morphological and mechanical properties. Despite their many advantages, there are also potential draw backs which must be appropriately evaluated(1). 

 

One consideration is with the evaluation of foreign impurities that can arise due to contact between the product and single-use systems. These foreign impurities (leachables or extractables) are compounds that are leached from these systems upon contact with the drug product. In terms of differentiating between leachables and extractables(2):

•    Extractables refer to a profile of extracted compounds observed in studies under harsh conditions. Hence, these have potential compound migration 
•    Leachables refer to those impurities that leach from the materials under real-use conditions and may be present in final drug products. Hence, these have actual compound migration 

 

Another factor is particulate matter, which, if on the surfaces of a single-use item, could detach and contaminate the drug product. Test methods are also required to quantify and identify particulate matter present on the interior surfaces(3).

 

This article considers why extractables and leachables testing is important, as well as some of the main areas for consideration. A key focus is on sterile items that come into contact with the drug substance or product. 

Regulations

 

The importance of extractables and leachables evaluation is stated in regulations like EU GMP Annex 1 (8.136): 

“The extractable and leachable profiles of the SUS and any impact on the quality of the product especially where the system is made from polymer-based materials should be evaluated. An assessment should be carried out for each component to evaluate the applicability of the extractable profile data. For components considered to be at high risk from leachables, including those that may absorb processed materials or those with extended material contact times, an assessment of leachable profile studies, including safety concerns, should be taken into consideration. If applying simulated processing conditions, these should accurately reflect the actual processing conditions and be based on a scientific rationale.”

Testing and design

 

While extractables and leachables can occur through any material contact during pharmaceutical processing, they are strongly associated with polymeric and elastomeric materials based on the additives used in the manufacturing process. These include antioxidants, lubricants and stabilisers.

This means, that before adopting a single-use system for use with a drug product, there is a need to assess the impact of leachables through screening designed to discover, identify and quantify any leachables. Ideally, this is performed during developmental work, prior to scale-up - however, sometimes there is the need to introduce new components into the process.

An effective design process helps with the identification of points of concern. Leachables can impact the drug product or earlier in the process, involving drug substances and excipients:

Before embarking on such a study, consideration needs to be given to:

•    What you are looking for
•    What are levels are acceptable 
•    What influences the generation of leachables (including the selected sterilisation method)(4)

 

Risk assessment

 

When assessing the potential suitability of single-use systems, the following factors must be considered and integrated into a risk assessment(5,6):

1.    Material compatibility
2.    Location in the process (the risk generally rises as the process moves downstream)
3.    Nature of product
4.    Surface area
5.    Contact temperature and time
6.    Pretreatment steps

 

Patient safety

Where leachables are detected, the adverse effect of them upon patient safety needs to be evaluated (through a formal risk assessment based on the toxicological profile for the leachable, the patient population, route of administration, dose and exposure/length of use)(7). This evaluation will include leachables that are sensitisers and those that are mutagens(8). Ideally, the leachable profile is evaluated by a toxicologist to assess the safety concern threshold.

 

Certain leachable compounds can also affect product efficacy and stability.

 

Analytical strategy

 

There are potentially many possible leachables (antimicrobials, colourants, film-forming agents etc.). Care needs to be given to the analytical strategy so that a complete leachables profile can be generated. Some useful guidance is contained in:

 

•    USP <1663>, covering extractables testing for pharmaceutical packaging
•    USP <1664>, covering leachables testing for pharmaceutical packaging
•    ISO10993-18 (2020), covering extractables and leachables for medical devices

 

The leachables profile is best assessed in relation to individual single-use items. Simply assessing the drug product may involve the use of a test without sufficient sensitivity or specificity and it will not provide sufficient clarity as to where in the process the impurity has entered.

 

Suitable analytical methods include(9):

•    High-Performance Liquid Chromatography (for organic compounds)
•    Gas Chromatography (for semi-volatile and volatile analytes)
•    GC with Headspace Sampling (for volatile compounds that are vaporised)

 

The chosen method(s) should be highly selective and sensitive analytical instruments. Another consideration is the suitability of the test sample. An appropriate sample preparation procedure is essential for the detection and accurate quantification of analytes of interest. 

 

To assess for extractables, the highest risk parameters need to be created. 


These include:

•    Time
•    Temperature
•    Use of a variety of solvents
•    Analysis by multiple methods

 

The aim is to separate, detect and identify any individual extractable. If extractables are detected, an extractable-leachable correlation should be established.

 

Summary

 

To ensure patient safety, single-use systems that come into contact with drug substances, excipients, or the drug product, must be evaluated for their ability to contribute leachables to the final product. The evaluation needs to be detailed and scientifically sound since risk-based assessments of extractables and leachables are required for regulatory submissions as part of product stability and quality. This consideration remains important as the range and scope of single-use, sterile items continues to expand(10). 

 

References

 

1.    Sandle, T. and Saghee, M. R. (2011): Some considerations for the implementation of disposable technology and single-use systems in biopharmaceuticals, Journal of Commercial Biotechnology, 17 (4): 319–329
2.    Kim Li, Gary Rogers, Yasser Nashed-Samuel, et al. Creating a Holistic Extractables and Leachables (E&L) Program for Biotechnology Products, PDA Journal of Pharmaceutical Science and Technology September 2015, 69 (5) 590-619
3.    Klaus Wormuth, Fanny Gaston, Melanie Gauthier, et al. Best Practices to Quantify and Identify Particulate Matter on the Interior Surfaces of Single-Use Systems, PDA Journal of Pharmaceutical Science and Technology January 2024, 78 (1) 90-99
4.    Sandle, T. and Saghee, M.R. (2012). Application of Sterilization by Gamma Radiation for Single-Use Disposable Technologies in the Biopharmaceutical Sector, Journal of GXP Compliance, 16 (2): 1-10
5.    Lynch M P. Extractables and Leachables Quality Concerns and Considerations for Ophthalmic and Injectable Products.” Am Pharm  Rev, May 2011
6.    Richter C et al, “Impact of extractables from rubber closures on protein stability under heat stress”. Eur J Pharm Biopharm, 2018, Vol 130, pp 22–29
7.    Patricia Parris, Geraldine Whelan, Anders Burild et al. Sensitization Assessment of Extractables and Leachables in Pharmaceuticals: ELSIE Database Analysis, PDA Journal of Pharmaceutical Science and Technology July 2024, 78 (4) 399-444
8.    Candice Johnson, Arianna Bassan, Doug Kiehl, et al. Characterizing Extractables and Leachables Chemical Space to Support In Silico Toxicological Hazard Assessments, PDA Journal of Pharmaceutical Science and Technology May 2024, 78 (3) 237-311
9.    Pang J, et al. Recognition and Identification of UV-Absorbing Leachables in EPREX Prefilled Syringes: An Unexpected Occurrence at a Formulation-Component Interface. PDA J. Pharm. Sci. Technol. 61 2007: 423–432
10.    Sandle, T. (2018) New Developments with Sterile Disposable Technology and Single-Use Systems for Aseptic Processing, BioPharma Asia, July / August, pp30-34

 

 

Want life science and pharmaceutical insights delivered to your inbox?

Subscribe to our mailing list and never miss another article.